“What works for men doesn’t work for everyone”: why cities need to start planning with women in mind

By Caroline Criado-Perez, May 25, 2016

from: citymetric.com

Last year, councillors for the city of London, in Ontario, Canada, spent 90 minutes discussing a 12 word addition to a document. The contentious sentence read, “Consider a gender lens during the development and execution of new policies”.

Harmless sounding, perhaps, but some of the male politicians felt the line impugned their honour. Bill Armstrong, representative of Ward 2 since the 90s, accused Maureen Cassidy, the councillor who introduced the offending line, of “questioning the integrity of our administration and suggesting they were doing practices that would be discriminatory”.

That, he said, was simply not the case, and “I’ve been there long enough to know” – a reference perhaps to his opponent’s more recent assumption of office. “Plain and simple,” he concluded, “all people are treated equally, so it doesn’t have to be said.”

The thing is, while Armstrong’s sentiment may be admirable, treating people equally has a long rap-sheet when it comes to achieving equal outcomes. That is to say, treating people equally often translates as treating people like men.

And not all people are men. Some of them (quite a lot actually) are women. Some of them are also girls – and boys. Sometimes people are men, but they aren’t the white, middle-aged, able-bodied men that are imagined when city halls are drawing up plans to treat people equally.

What all this means is that what works for men, as imagined by city hall, doesn’t necessarily work for everyone else. By treating us in a way that suits this male ideal, the rest of us are disadvantaged – often in surprising ways.

For example, I bet you’ve never thought about snow clearing as a gendered issue. Neither had city officials in Karlskoga, in Sweden. “The community development staff made jokes about how at least snow is something the gender people won’t get involved in,” explained Bruno Rudström, one of the city’s gender equality strategists.

But on reflection, they realised that even something as seemingly neutral as snow-clearing, actually could have a markedly different impact on men and women, due to the gender split in travel style. Women are more likely than men to walk, bike, and use public transport, whereas men are more likely to drive. By prioritising clearing the roads, the city was prioritising the way men choose to travel, despite the fact that walking or pushing a stroller though 10cm of snow is much harder than driving a car through it.

So the city changed the order of snow-clearing to focus on the pavements and cycle paths first, particularly around schools. As an unexpected by-product, it found a marked decrease in injuries: pedestrians are three times as likely as motorists to be injured in accidents due to slippery conditions.

Parks are another area you might not immediately think of as gendered spaces – but a study in Vienna found that, after the age of nine, there was a dramatic decline in the number of girls using them. The reason behind this decline was not that girls stopped liking the parks: rather, if they had to compete with boys for space, they tended to lose, because they were less assertive.


more on: CityMetric

Mannequins erected in London’s Marble Arch to promote Safer Cities for Women Day. Image: Action Aid.

July 2016

It’s the Culture, Stupid

It's the Culture, Stupid curatorial statement for the International Architecture Biennale Rotterdam, from executive director George Brugmans by Orhan Ayyüce via archinect.com Culture is where we imagine, where we create the narratives that bind us [...]

June 2016

Apartheid’s Urban Legacy, in Striking Aerial Photographs

Apartheid's Urban Legacy, in Striking Aerial Photographs by TANVI MISRA from: citylab.com An American used drones to capture the color lines still stark in South African cities. Johnny Miller was just starting out as a photographer [...]

Does Makoko Floating School’s collapse threaten the whole slum’s future?

Does Makoko Floating School's collapse threaten the whole slum's future? via The Guardian Multiple award-winning Makoko Floating School was a beacon of hope in this Lagos slum until its collapse this week. Now some [...]

The woman behind stunning sustainable homes from bamboo

The woman behind stunning sustainable homes from bamboo. by Derek Markham via treehugger.com Elora Hardy and her team of designers, artisans, and builders at Ibuku are reimagining sustainable building, using one of nature's strongest and most [...]

What Jane Means: 4 Women Urbanists Reflect on Their Relationship to Jane Jacobs

What Jane Means: 4 Women Urbanists Reflect on Their Relationship to Jane Jacobs by Rebecca Greenwald via metropolismag.com Jane Jacobs’ writing and advocacy marked one of the first times a woman’s voice entered the field of [...]

From Floating Food Forests to Vacant Lot Crops, Urban Farming Is Taking Root Across America

From Floating Food Forests to Vacant Lot Crops, Urban Farming Is Taking Root Across America by Sher Watts Spooner from: dailykos.com More than 1,500 community gardens have been started on vacant land in Detroit alone in recent [...]

Hard-Pressed Rust Belt Cities Go Green to Aid Urban Revival

Hard-Pressed Rust Belt Cities Go Green to Aid Urban Revival by winifred bird from: e360.yale.edu Gary, Indiana is joining Detroit and other fading U.S. industrial centers in an effort to turn abandoned neighborhoods and factory [...]

May 2016

Air and water problems are worsening on a global scale, U.N. says

Air and water problems are worsening on a global scale, U.N. says By Chris Mooney from: washingtonpost.com In a sweeping synthesis of global data, the United Nations Environment Programme has intensively catalogued environmental assaults across [...]

Pakistan’s first female architect to receive Japan’s prestigious prize

Yasmeen LARI, receiving the FUKUOKA PRIZE from: fukuoka-prize.org     Ms. Yasmeen Lari founded the Heritage Foundation of Pakistan and has been involved in the preservation and conservation of historical buildings, while also designing contemporary [...]

Good urban planning can help the environment

Good urban planning can help the environment from: washingtonpost.com Urbanization itself is not responsible for the environmental threats facing the world. Unplanned and poorly managed urbanization is. It is important to note the distinction between [...]